Monday, April 25, 2011

Review: Abandon by Meg Cabot

Tags: YA, paranormal, retelling, Greek mythology


Pierce Oliviera’s life started unraveling the day she died and met the man who she had once met in a cemetery when she was very young. The man, John, occupies a space between the dead and the living, and seems to want to keep Pierce as a companion for himself. However, Pierce managed to escape, although John has continued to show up in her life whenever she least wants him to, and create lots of trouble.

Now, Pierce is trying to start over on Isla Huesos, an island off Florida. Returning to her family’s roots, however, seems to make her life intersect again with John’s…


ABANDON is the first book in Meg Cabot’s latest YA trilogy, a retelling of the Hades and Persephone Greek myth. Unfortunately, I have found myself less and less satisfied with Cabot’s books, and ABANDON, while marginally better than Cabot’s Airhead series, still uses too many of her usual writing techniques—little forward action, a heavy emphasis on flashback—to endear itself to me completely.

I like Pierce: she is, in my opinion, a little mellower than many of Cabot’s protagonists. And at the beginning of ABANDON I was reminded very much of earlier Meg Cabot books that I loved, such as All-American Girl. Pierce displays a sense of poise that may or may not be the result of her constant encounters with near-death experiences, but nevertheless is very appealing. I even have a tiny little crush on John, who’s protective but not overbearingly so, and really very sweet in his interest in Pierce.

It was the way the story was presented, however, that didn’t gel with me. Practically every other chapter is a flashback. Granted, they are very important flashbacks, explaining how Pierce first encountered John and showing her subsequent (unwanted, but lifesaving) encounters with him and the troubles he has caused for her. However, why does the story have to be presented half in flashback? Pierce’s backstory was so much more interesting than her present story of being the new student at her school, making new friends (or nemeses) of questionable characterization, and slowly uncovering her family’s very melodramatic secret. Why couldn’t the story simply be presented chronologically? I think it might’ve made for a more engaging read, instead of my being frustrated that, once again, Meg Cabot was resorting to cliff-hangery comments that are supposed to pique readers’ interest and have us reading frantically to figure out whatever happened, but instead feels like trickery, a manipulation of our emotions.

Overall, though, I think ABANDON will be a great read for younger readers, particularly those who have read much of Cabot’s books or other paranormal reads. It has an interesting pair of lead characters and decently good writing. I just couldn’t fully get behind the awkward story structure.

Cover discussion: Considering how I cover lusted after this a long time ago, I think it's safe to say that I am attracted to it and just might want a make-out session with it.

Scholastic / April 26, 2011 / Hardcover / 320pp. / $17.99

Sent by publisher for review. Thanks, Scholastic!


  1. Great review! I've been a little hesitant about this one because while I really like the premise, I haven't been enjoying Meg Cabot's recent novels as much as her old ones... so I'm glad the protagonist is like All-American Girl, which I used to LOVE. Ugh, I don't know if I'll be trying this one after hearing about that awkward story structure, especially since I struggle the most with not well-incorporated flashbacks. I'll keep an eye out though, and thanks for the honest review! :)

  2. I'm not sure if this one is for me. However, I found it interesting that its a Hades and Persephone re-telling, since I just finished reading The Goddess Test.

  3. I feel much better knowing I haven't been the only one enjoying Cabot's latest works less and less. She seems to of hopped on the "supernatural" bandwagon. I'm holding on to hope that I'll enjoy this one, but this review is not making me feel hopeful.

  4. Thanks for the review. I'm cautious about reading Abandon since I didn't enjoy the Airhead series much either but the concept is interesting enough so I'll hold out.

  5. I'm not really sure whether to read this or not. Sometimes I read very positive reviews, but mostly I've just found mixed ones. I might wait for my summer vacation since I always have lesser expectations for books that I just want to read at the beach. :D
    Thank you for your great review!


  6. Exactly how I felt. I missed Cabot's humor.

  7. Great review Steph. I'm still debating whether to get this one or not. It sounds right up my street, but I don't have a good history with Meg Cabot. :/

  8. The cover is so gorgeous. it's totally different from the previous series, lets call Mediator.
    I hope the flashback wont confuse me.
    I really want to read this book.

  9. Sorry to hear this one wasn't as good as you'd hoped! I've been a huge Meg Cabot fan since reading her Princess Diaries books as a teen, but I'll admit that I haven't enjoyed many of the adult fic novels she's written lately (including Size 12 Is Not Fat, which could have been... so much better).

    Maybe I'll give this series a shot, though -- it's hard to let Meg go!

  10. I have to agree that Cabot's books always use the same techniques. I really liked the mediator series, and maybe I'll give this series a chance.

  11. I found this one slow going throught 3/4ths of the book. The last chapter or two was good enough for me to be compelled to read the next to see what happens but I'm not going to prioritize it.


Hello! I'm so excited to read what you have to say. Due to high amounts of spam, I'm forced to disabled anonymous comments for the time being. Sorry for any inconvenience this causes, and I hope you can understand and still appreciate the content here!


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...